Governance

Board Evaluation for Group Companies: A Practical Annual Process

By ATTPL HOLDCO / ATTPL GROUP Editorial Team · · 2 min read

How business groups in India can run a simple, useful annual evaluation of their boards, committees and directors — legal requirements, a step-by-step process and how to act on results.

Board of directors of an Indian business group reviewing an annual evaluation report in a meeting room

What the law expects

A board that never looks at its own performance rarely improves. For a business group with several companies, a short annual evaluation of each board, its committees and individual directors is one of the cheapest ways to raise the quality of decisions.

Listed companies and certain larger public companies must carry out a formal annual evaluation of the board, its committees and individual directors and describe the process in the board's report. Independent directors also review non-independent directors and the chairperson in a separate meeting. Many private and unlisted group companies are not required to do this, but adopting a light version brings the same discipline across the group.

A simple five-step process

  • Agree criteria: strategy, risk oversight, quality of information, meeting conduct, attendance and contribution
  • Use a short questionnaire (10 to 15 questions, rated 1 to 5 with comments) for each board and committee
  • Have a neutral person, such as the company secretary or an independent director, collect and summarise responses
  • Discuss the summary in a dedicated board session, not as the last agenda item
  • Record three to five actions with owners and dates, and review them at the next evaluation
Board of directors of an Indian business group reviewing an annual evaluation report in a meeting room - key points

Making it useful for a group

Use the same core questionnaire for every group company so results can be compared, and add a few questions specific to each business. Look for patterns: late board papers, weak risk discussion or poor follow-up of actions often repeat across entities. Link the findings to your board committees and to director training plans. Group-wide policies such as a delegation of authority matrix make the evaluation easier because roles are clear.

How ATTPL can help

ATTPL Consultancy supports company secretarial work, board processes and compliance for growing groups, and ATTPL Legal can review governance documents. Contact the ATTPL HOLDCO team to plan a group-wide governance review.

Frequently asked questions

Is board evaluation mandatory for private companies?

Generally not for most private companies, but it is good practice. Listed companies and specified public companies must evaluate and disclose the process.

Who should run the evaluation?

Usually the chairperson or the nomination committee, with the company secretary or an independent director collecting responses.

Should results be shared with directors?

Yes. Share an anonymised summary and agree actions; individual feedback is best given privately by the chairperson.

Sources and further reading

This article is general information, not legal or governance advice. Requirements depend on each company's class and status; consult a company secretary or advocate.

Related articles

ATTPL Watermark